Service personnel have to be disciplined and follow military rules and commands. The military has ways of dealing with people who don’t follow the rules and commands. One of these ways is a court-martial.
The Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ) is the body of laws that governs the actions and conduct of service members, including what actions or conduct constitute violations of those laws. In particular, Article 92 applies to disobeying orders or regulations. Also, Articles 90 and 91 apply to disobeying an order with intent.
Disciplinary actions against military service members would not be possible without the military justice system. When service members disobey orders, military service prosecutors may file charges under UCMJ Article 92 or, depending on who gave the order, Article 90 or 91.
Disobeying an order does not always result in a court-martial, as many assume. Service members are obligated to obey lawful orders, and military law recognizes this duty.
Here’s an explanation about scenarios wherein noncompliance with a given order can lead to a court-martial. This post also talks about the conditions the UCMJ imposes and the consequences service members could face following their disobedient act.
The three articles most often involved
Article 90 is about a person who, willfully, disobeys a lawful order issued by a superior commissioned officer.
Article 91 is the part that covers conduct addressed to a warrant officer, a noncommissioned officer, and a petty officer who performs his duty and includes willful disobedience of his lawful orders, among others. Neither article sets a specific penalty, and punishment is left to the discretion of the court-martial. Keep in mind that Article 90 allows death in time of war.
The most extensive article on this subject is Article 92. This article deals with failure to obey order or regulation. It encompasses three acts. First, there is disobedience to a general order or lawful regulation, which includes orders issued by senior commanders.
Secondly, there is the refusal to obey other lawful orders when a service member is aware of the existence of the order and has a duty to obey. Thirdly, there is dereliction of duty. Similar to Article 91, the law does not state a penalty for this offense.
Willful versus knowing
The way these provisions are worded makes a real difference. Article 90 mentions willful disobedience, suggesting that there is an intention to disobey the superior.
The second form of violation in Article 92 is premised on knowledge of the order. This leads to a situation in which a person who is unaware of the order could be placed in an entirely different position from that of a person who decides to ignore it.
The third type of misconduct is negligent or willful dereliction of duty, which requires proof that the person had a duty and failed to perform it.
What tends to shape a case
For insubordinate conduct, factors to look at include the type of order, who gave it, whether it was written or verbal, how it was delivered, and whether the member had prior training.
The evidence may include witness testimony, emails, and log entries from the military unit. This information is important in cases where UCMJ 92, Article 15, administrative separation, and court-martial take place.
Finding counsel familiar with military cases
People facing these charges, and their families, often look for counsel familiar with military cases. Criminal defense firms that list military law among their practice areas, such as the W. James Payne Law Firm in North Carolina, represent service members facing courts-martial and administrative discharge proceedings.
Where to read the rules
The statutes include descriptions of the crimes, while the process of charging and trying the crime is described in the Manual for Courts-Martial, which was prepared by the Joint Service Committee on Military Justice in the Department of Defense and issued by executive order of the President.
The only way to confirm one knows the meaning of willfulness, knowledge, and duty is to look at the article’s language.
Willful disobedience of a military order is an act, but not all instances of it will necessarily undergo the court-martial process. Under the UCMJ and the Manual for Courts-Martial, the difference between willful disobedience of an order and neglect of duty lies in the person’s state of mind, since willful disobedience requires intent, while neglect can rest on carelessness.
Basically, the Uniform Code of Military Justice says that military personnel must obey all lawful orders. A clearly unlawful order does not have to be followed.


